Expert Review: Why 50 First Dates Is Perfect Feel-Good Theatre

4.5
★★★★★

Expert Rating

The Verdict

50 First Dates: The Musical captures all the heart and humor of the beloved film while adding catchy songs and theatrical magic. This feel-good romantic comedy explores themes of love, memory, and second chances with warmth, wit, and genuine emotional depth. Directed by Tony winner Casey Nicholaw, this world premiere promises to be the perfect date night musical.

What Makes It Special

  • Beloved Source Material: Based on the hit Adam Sandler and Drew Barrymore film that captured hearts worldwide with its unique romantic premise.
  • Tony-Winning Direction: Casey Nicholaw ("The Book of Mormon," "Mean Girls") brings his signature blend of humor and heart.
  • Catchy New Songs: Original music and lyrics by David Rossmer and Steve Rosen capture the tropical, romantic spirit of the story.
  • Perfect Cast: Georgina Castle and Josh St. Clair lead a talented ensemble in bringing these beloved characters to life.

Perfect For

Fans of romantic comedies, musical theatre enthusiasts, date nights, and anyone seeking uplifting entertainment that celebrates love conquering all obstacles.

Everything You Need to Know

The Story

Henry is a commitment-phobic marine veterinarian enjoying a carefree vacation in Hawaii when he meets Lucy, a charming art teacher. It's love at first sight, but Henry soon discovers Lucy suffers from short-term memory loss - she wakes up every day with no memory of him.

The Challenge

Determined to win her heart, Henry must find creative ways to make Lucy fall in love with him every single day. From elaborate schemes to heartfelt gestures, he discovers that true love means being willing to start over again and again.

The Heart

Beneath the comedy lies a deeper story about the nature of love, memory, and what it means to truly know someone. The musical explores how love can transcend even the most challenging circumstances.

Musical Adaptation

The stage version expands on the film's themes while adding new musical numbers that explore the characters' inner lives and the tropical Hawaiian setting that becomes almost a character itself.

Musical Numbers

The musical features original songs that capture the romantic, comedic, and emotional journey of Henry and Lucy's story:

  • "Every Single Day" - Henry's opening number about his commitment-free lifestyle
  • "Perfect Moment" - The romantic duet when Henry and Lucy first meet
  • "Start Again" - Henry's realization that he must win Lucy's love anew each day
  • "Island Paradise" - Ensemble number celebrating the Hawaiian setting
  • "Remember Me" - Lucy's poignant solo about her condition
  • "Love Finds a Way" - The uplifting finale about love conquering all

Music & Lyrics: David Rossmer and Steve Rosen have created a score that balances humor with genuine emotion, incorporating tropical rhythms and contemporary musical theatre styles.

Practical Information

Show Times

  • Tuesday - Saturday: 7:30pm
  • Saturday: 2:30pm & 7:30pm
  • Sunday: 3:00pm

Getting There

  • Train: Victoria Station (3 mins walk)
  • Underground: Victoria (District, Circle, Victoria lines)
  • Buses: Multiple routes to Victoria
  • Parking: NCP Victoria and surrounding areas

Theatre Information

  • Intimate 168-seat venue
  • Fully accessible with step-free access
  • Air conditioning throughout
  • Bar and refreshments available
  • Known for developing new musicals

Content Guidance

Recommended for ages 12+ due to adult themes and romantic content. The show deals with memory loss and medical conditions with sensitivity and humor.